How to Request & Verify a Contractor’s Certificate of Insurance (COI) in Ontario

How to Request & Verify a Contractor’s Certificate of Insurance (COI) in Ontario

Topic

Learn how to request, verify, and evaluate a contractor's Certificate of Insurance (COI) in Ontario. Ensure liability and coverage compliance before hiring.

Before you hire a contractor or subcontractor for any business project in Ontario, one of the most critical steps is confirming they carry valid insurance. A Certificate of Insurance (COI) is your proof that a contractor is protected—and by extension, so are you. Here’s a practical, step-by-step guide to requesting and verifying a COI for your next project.

What Is a Certificate of Insurance (COI)?

Understand what a COI is and why it's a crucial document for confirming contractor liability coverage.

A Certificate of Insurance is a formal document issued by an insurer that confirms a contractor has active liability insurance. It typically includes:

  • Policyholder name
  • Insurance company details
  • Policy types and coverage limits
  • Effective and expiration dates
  • Additional insured parties (if applicable)

The COI acts as evidence that your contractor has Commercial General Liability (CGL) and possibly Errors & Omissions (E&O), Workers' Compensation, or Builder’s Risk insurance.

Why COIs Matter for Business Owners in Ontario

A Certificate of Insurance (COI) is a formal document issued by an insurance provider that verifies a contractor holds active liability coverage. It outlines key policy details such as coverage types, limits, effective dates, and the insurer’s contact information.  

This document provides peace of mind to clients and project owners, ensuring that the contractor is financially protected in case of accidents, property damage, or third-party injury. Requiring a COI helps manage risk and confirms that the contractor meets insurance obligations before any work begins.

Requesting and verifying a COI protects you from legal and financial exposure. Without proper coverage:

  • You may be liable for accidents on-site
  • Your property may be at risk from uninsured damage
  • Your project may be delayed or shut down due to compliance violations

A valid COI helps ensure that your contractor meets your legal and contractual requirements.

When Should You Request a COI?

Discover the right time to request a Certificate of Insurance from your contractor for maximum protection.

You should request a Certificate of Insurance (COI) before any work begins, ideally during the contract negotiation phase, to ensure the contractor has valid and sufficient coverage. This protects you from potential liability if accidents, damage, or injuries occur during the project, and allows time to verify the policy details or request additional coverage if needed.

You should request a Certificate of Insurance:

  • Before signing any contractor agreement
  • Prior to any work starting on your property
  • When hiring subcontractors for client projects
  • When renewing contracts on long-term projects

Always make it a condition of the contract.

How to Request a Certificate of Insurance

Use these best practices to ensure your contractor provides a valid and complete COI every time.

1. Ask the Contractor Directly

Most reputable contractors expect this request and can forward the COI from their broker.

2. Request It in Writing

Include COI requirements in your bid documents or contract language. Specify the minimum coverage levels (e.g., $2M CGL, $1M E&O).

3. Ask for Additional Insured Status

Request to be named as an “additional insured.” This extends their liability coverage to include your business.

How to Verify a COI is Valid

Follow this checklist to confirm your contractor’s insurance is real, current, and compliant.

1. Check the Effective and Expiry Dates

Ensure the policy is active for the full duration of your project.

2. Review Coverage Types and Limits

Look for Commercial General Liability, Errors & Omissions, WSIB, and Builder’s Risk if relevant. Check for adequate limits.

3. Confirm the Issuing Broker or Insurer

Call the insurer or broker listed on the COI to verify that the policy is real and current.

4. Match Business Names

Ensure the name on the COI matches your contractor’s legal business name or corporate registration.

Red Flags to Watch For

Stay alert to common signs that a COI may be outdated, fake, or insufficient for your project’s risk.

  • COI missing coverage limits
  • Expired policy dates
  • Personal lines insurer (not commercial)
  • Contractor hesitant or delaying COI request

Always follow up with the issuing broker if something seems off.

COI Requirements for St. Thomas, Ontario Projects

Understand the standard and enhanced insurance expectations for local construction and contracting work.

Local regulations or clients may require:

  • $2 million minimum Commercial General Liability
  • WSIB clearance certificate
  • Builder’s Risk coverage on structural jobs
  • E&O coverage for design-build firms or consultants

Municipal projects often have stricter COI requirements. Verify with the City of St. Thomas if needed.

Conclusion:  

A simple COI request can save your business thousands in legal fees, fines, or project delays. Whether you’re a business owner, project manager, or general contractor, verifying insurance upfront is the smart, risk-aware move.

If you need help reviewing a contractor’s coverage or setting up your own business liability protection, contact us today to speak with a Reith & Associates advisor.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is the purpose of a Certificate of Insurance?

A COI proves that a contractor or vendor holds valid insurance. It helps protect your business from third-party claims, injuries, or uninsured property damage during a project.

Is it legally required to ask for a COI in Ontario?

While not mandated by law, many municipalities and clients require it as a best practice and contractual condition to manage liability.

What types of insurance should appear on a contractor’s COI?

You should see Commercial General Liability, Errors & Omissions (if applicable), WSIB, and possibly Builder’s Risk coverage depending on the scope of work.

Can I accept a COI that is set to expire soon?

No. Make sure the COI remains valid throughout the project timeline. Request an updated version if the expiration date falls before project completion.

What does "additional insured" mean on a COI?

It means your business is also protected under the contractor’s policy. This provides direct access to their liability coverage if a claim arises.